Engineering an Innovation System for Defence Industrial Corridors
Sub Title : The country`s dream for self reliance can be brought to fruition if it is well strategized
Issues Details : Vol 15 Issue 4 Sep – Oct 2021
Author : Lt Gen (Dr) N B Singh, PVSM, AVSM, VSM, ADC
Page No. : 33
Category : Military Affairs
: September 30, 2021
The country`s dream forself reliance can be brought to fruition provided it is intelligently strategized with military taking ownership and MOD driving this change with innovative policies. A collaborative approach entailing everyone`s effort can provide the critical mass to make the DICs sustainable
Defence Industrial Corridors were established to spearhead the Govt`s initiative of Atmanirbhar Bharat by creating new environmentally and technologically advanced areas that hosted constituents of the country`s defence industrial base, innovative industries and their associated knowledge workers. The Government has set up defence industrial corridors (DIC) in Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu. In pursuance of this, the Ministry of Defence identified six nodes in Uttar Pradesh Defence Corridor and five nodes in Tamil Nadu Defence Corridor. On 26 July 2021, the Ministry of Defence informed Rajya Sabha about the land acquisition for the two DICs. These defence corridors aim to create a well-planned and efficient ecosystem leading to increased defence production in the country. As per present forecasts the UPDIC has the potential to generate employment for more than 16,700 persons, and the TNDIC has the potential to generate employment for 25,000 persons in the coming years.
Uttar Pradesh Defence Industrial Corridor
Uttar Pradesh DIC is being set up by the Uttar Pradesh Expressways Industrial Development Authority (UPEIDA). It consists of six nodal points namely; Agra, Aligarh, Chitrakoot, Jhansi, Lucknow and encompasses 197 hectares. A stand out advantage is the proximity to a large number of R&D establishments, Ordnance factories, DPSUs and presence of military`s integral industrial base and top notch academic institutions. UPEIDA has inked 55 MoUs with private industries, worth potential investments of Rs.7449.33 crore. Industries are expected to be provided with uninterrupted power and water, single window approvals, highway connectivity, labour permits and simplified procedures for quick reimbursement of incentives and subsidies.
Tamil Nadu Defence Industrial Corridor
Tamil Nadu Defence Industrial Corridor is being set up by the Government of Tamil Nadu. It consists of five nodal points i.e. Chennai, Coimbatore, Hosur, Salem, Tiruchirappalli and is spread over an area of 283 hectares. Tamil Nadu Industrial Development Corporation (TIDCO), the nodal agency, has inked 22 MoUs with private/public industries, worth Rs.4800 crore. With a vast network of DPSUs and OFs, Tamil Nadu is a highly suitable destination for the defence sector with a number of inherent advantages like a well developed industrial base, network of airports and seaports, global data connectivity with submarine cables, large FDI receipts, availability of high calibre skilled labour and presence of a large number of defence PSUs in the region.
The Make in India initiative is a strategic step towards Defence Industrial capability building and long term technology security. It is important that dependence on foreign platforms and sourcing of military capability from overseas is reduced or else the likelihood of capability failure at crucial times will always be high, since crucial dependencies are retained by suppliers. It is also important from the strategic assurance and influence angle. A self-sustaining indigenous defence industrial base should be the envisaged end state two to three decades later, where innovation and injection of new ideas contribute to achieving a battle winning edge over the adversary. At least in the field of general munitions, energetics, armaments and soldier systems one cannot depend on panic procurements from abroad. The crucial element of demand from the military exists. The supply side is what needs to be addressed by designing a self sustaining eco system that drives innovation at the DICs and regularly moves these into the development pipeline.
Innovation System of DIC
It is essential to build an environment to mesh in extant indigenous capabilities and foreign technology to craft out systems that the military wants. If DICs are left to freewheel without a strategy – the end result may be half baked as has happened with some IT parks – unstable, unbalanced, uncoordinated and ultimately unsustainable. Instead, it needs to be scripted according to a Strategic Plan and pre-defined milestones. The DIC innovation system will ideally comprise the following actors and building blocks:-
Prime Contractor or Systems Integrator. An entity with industrial capability to deliver a complex system or product like a combat vehicle, ship or aircraft.
Partial System Manufacturer. These manufacture independent systems which while possessing independent purpose, are relevant when integrated into a complex system e.g. an air defence missile.
Sub-System Manufacturer. They manufacture systems which give a capability to the complex system only when integrated with the platform e.g. propulsion system.
Component Manufacturers. These entities generally MSMEs, provide finished assemblies/aggregates which form part of sub-systems.
Design Houses. These are knowledge based organisations (Design Authority) with unique systems engineering skills, a suite of modern modelling& simulation processes & tools and facilities to test & prove at sub-system level. They generally pick up sub-contracts from prime SIs.
Academic Partners. Academic partners provide finance from research grants, consulting, mentoring, lab testing and facilitate technology transfer to move an innovation to manufacture.
Innovation in Innovation
In order to achieve the national vision of self reliance in military systems, it is important that a long term plan is put in place. Israel and China were in near similar condition as India during the seventies, just after the Yom Kippur war. Israel was dependent mainly on western weapons and China on vintage equipment being manufactured as a sequel to technology transfers from Soviet Union. Post 1973, Israel made the shift by adopting the human capital intensive growth strategy, focussing on creating a knowledge base & innovation. The Chinese adopted the IDAR (introduce, digest, absorb &
re-innovate) strategy of inserting current technologies into vintage systems and later developing weapons de-novo.
- Israel. Growth of the defence industry was achieved by a blend of imported technology and Israeli innovation. Israeli firms purchased manufacturing rights and entered into collaborative ventures with foreign companies mostly with Govt support. In 1964 Motorola set up an R&D facility, followed by IBM and Intel in 1974. The corridor from Tel Aviv to Haifa emerged as a centre for ICT. A well planned and efficient government intervention facilitated emergence of Government-owned conglomerates like Israel Military Industries, Israeli Aerospace Industries along with a host of private companies. A focussed R&D funding programme providing up to 66% match by Govt for innovative projects with no repayment requirements and a creative human capital development initiative under Israeli Defence Force`s elite technology oriented units, helped in pushing innovations into the development pipeline with the military providing the initial market.
- China. China has engineered an impressive transformation in which external technology transfers and the industry’s ability to absorb these inputs and convert into localized output has played a central role. China has pursued an approach to obtain defence and dual-use civil-military technology transfers using a wide variety of means from spending heavily on importing technologies, engaging in joint ventures as well as industrial and cyber espionage. The IDAR strategy has undergone several iterations over the years. Initially, most of the innovation occurred in Govt institutions. The first steps were directed towards revitalising national capabilities through small number of programmes. This was followed by reforming the science and technology system and placing emphasis on high technology start-ups and technology parks, import of technology and its assimilation. In the last decade, medium and long term plans for Science and Technology were rolled out, pledging to increase R&D expenditure to 2.5 % of GDP and a marked shift towards innovation driven by business entities. Another good feature is that the funding is either mission oriented, specifying targets to be achieved or excellence oriented, focussing on quality and break out technologies. Capacity building is sought to be promoted in areas where capability gaps are identified. It is also called the civil military fusion strategy.
A Tailored Collaborative Strategy
How does India embark on its journey of AtmanirbharBharat ? A unique advantage is that the local industrial base is modern, matching global standards, is connected world widewith availability of creative local talent. The same cannot be said for the supply chain which lacks both capability and connectivity. In defence manufacturing, the fact that the country has demonstrated capabilities to design and develop its own fighter, helicopter, tank, howitzers, frigates, submarines and aircraft carrier indicates the versatile industrial capabilities that have been created. However, this has been achieved mostly using foreign sub systems like propulsion, navigation, sensors, weapons, etc. This vital capability gap has to be plugged through an innovation system. It is time to allow private enterprises to join in not as competitors but as high impact partners to address technology gaps. If more than 50% of the sub systems for Tejas or Arjun are imported, it is time these are indigenised. The military needs to encourage these ventures and not have a rethink after years of painstaking efforts and investments. The Technology Development Fund/IDEX initiative should provide mission oriented funding for innovations that seek to address such capability gaps. Govt backed venture funds and recruitment of overseas talent could also be considered. DICs have to not only create world class infrastructure to attract investments but more importantly a collaborative work culture of cooperation.
From a military operational context, it is important that the DIC innovation system focusses on System Effectiveness i.e. capability of platforms to accomplish stipulated missions. Most of the time the military has realised that foreign know- how when deployed, has thrown up technical challenges that inhibit full scale exploitation e.g. in the current deployment at LAC several performance capability gaps would have been noticed in equipment capability. These need to be addressed on a war footing. I propose the ODEI approach as a cost effective strategy to provide the initial ballast to Make in India Onboard technology, Deploy, Evaluate and Innovate. A collaborative mindset will be essential to avoid wastages and inhibit `requirements drift` where QRs get transformed with changes in the hierarchy. The corner stone of this strategy has to be a commitment by all stakeholders to the self reliance call by the PM and hand holding of the industry. A large portion of Israel`s ICT achievements have been attributed to IDF`s Unit 8200 and Talpiot programme that played a key role in providing advanced training and skill development. Military institutions like MCEME, MCTE, CME, INS Shivaji could provide the critical mass needed by the industry to build foundational know how. This is the crux of what ails the indigenous innovation system – a clinical reluctance to knowledge sharing by the military in the name of security.
Clusters and Anchor Firms
Industrial clusters are geographic concentrations of interconnected companies and institutions in a particular field. It is not limited to one industry but an array of linked industries including suppliers and customers. (Michael Porter 1998). Clusters may come up due to natural advantages like low costs, pleasant climate, workforce with specific skills and historical presence of an industry e.g. Kanpur could be transformed into a special clothing , small arms and ammunition cluster due to presence of industries in this region who could act as anchor firms. However, for it to flourish, the product range has to be expanded to a wide variety of combat clothing and soldier systems. Similarly, Chennai has great potential to becoming a hub for land systems due to presence of tank factory and a host of automobile manufacturing units in its vicinity. The Govt can accelerate the process by improving overall business environment, providing marketing services, finance, information sharing, pooling resources, collective working and more importantly attracting anchor firms.
Anchor industries are either pre- existing successful local industries or are established by the Govt to create an ecosystem in which MSMEs, start-ups and buyers gather around anchor firms to create value e.g. the Ordnance Factory at Amethi slated to manufacture AK 203 assault rifle. If properly strategized as an anchor firm it can create a small arms cluster around Lucknow -Kanpur Bundelkhand region, where not only the rifle, its components but also associated day and night sights, ammunition, firing range equipment, simulators, can be manufactured. With a long term plan, it could become an international hub for manufacture of soldier systems and general munitions. Fig below explains how in case of a simple product like bullet, a collaborative workshare between OF and private entities (A,B,C) can be implemented to enhance quality and efficiency. It can then be rolled forward for more complex munitions. Needless to mention the projected global demand for this ammunition is around 5-7 billion rounds annually.
With the core mission and vision of Atmanirbhar Bharat having been spelt out by the PM, it is time a roll out plan is configured at the MOD spelling out actions with time lines. A Capability Evaluation Board could be considered to provide the strategic direction. The following are some actions that could help channelize efforts and resources to accelerate the setting up of DICs :-
- Rolling out an indigenization plan for spare parts and MRO kits to address hollowness and rev up MSMEs .Mandatory outsourcing of some reset activities and spares parts supply could be considered.
- Initiating technology refresh initiatives in selected vintage systems with the aim of enhancing equipment capabilities and reducing life cycle readiness costs.
- Fast track indigenization of vital sub systems
(propulsion, weapon pack, navigation) of indigenously manufactured weapon platforms by designating a few numbers as experimental platforms.
- Commissioning of sub system level development projects for combat vehicles, warships and aircraft with Govt support and objective of integrating these into futuristic platforms. This is the key to self reliance in the long run.
- Launching of major de-novo design and development projects related to land, marine and aerial platforms with the stipulation that these be integrated with indigenously manufactured/developed systems.
- Launching of excellence oriented research projects in new technologies aiming to create a DARPA like effect.
- Government needs to be proactive in attracting anchor firms like aircraft manufacturers, unmanned systems manufacturers, robotics, space, ICT to DICs which will lead to other firms gravitating towards the corridors. The clearance given to the Tata Airbus combine to make C295MW transport planes is a significant step in creating an anchor industry.
The country`s dream forself reliance can be brought to fruition within the Amrit Kaal i.e. next 25 years, provided it is intelligently strategized with military taking ownership and MOD driving this change with innovative policies. A collaborative approach entailing SabkaPrayas everyone`s effort can provide the critical mass to make the DICs sustainable. Two specific areas to be addressed are people`s competencies and technology gaps. Using the skills and creativity of home–grown talent, the entrepreneurialism and social networks of NRIs and a more supportive environment for research and development, it is possible to create an Indian Innovation System to fulfil the dream of every Indian – equipping the military with Proudly Made in India weapons. Time to come out from dependence on know how of others.